Short answer: It is difficult but definitely not impossible to outperform hedge funds and asset management firms over the long run.
Long answer: There isn’t a direct answer to this.
Hedge funds and big trading firms have billions in capital, teams of experienced and highly qualified portfolio managers, traders and analysts, cutting edge hardware and software infrastructure and real-time access to material market information.
Retail traders have a rusty old laptop, a free trading software and questionable Wi-Fi.
Fortunately, the good news is institutional traders and retail traders have different edges in the market. Retail traders can succeed if they know how to play their game right. To understand the difference between us and them, let’s look at the advantages and disadvantages retail traders have compared to the big boys.
- David vs Goliath!
1. Small Capacity
Hedge funds have large capital base and this limits the markets they can access. As retail traders, we can fly under the radar and tackle markets that doesn’t have enough liquidity to absorb the big boys.
2. Lack of Investment Mandate
Some hedge funds and most asset management firms have investment mandates they have to follow. A Long-only APAC Equity Fund has to absorb the beta risk of Asian equities (unless they hold 100% cash which is unlikely) even if they are bearish on Asian Equities. Retail traders on the other hand can adapt their play to the varying market conditions.
3. Low Execution Risk
Imagine if an asset management fund wants to buy a significant stake into Company Banana. This will definitely move the market. Other players may notice and join the trade. This pushes the price higher and raises the fund’s entry price.
Retails traders rarely move the market. Rarely do people care what they do – maybe except for this guy: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2014-09-25/mystery-man-moving-japan-made-more-than-1-million-trades.html
4. Funds experience Capital Withdrawals
Capital withdrawals tend to be disruptive to the investment strategy. Withdrawals may cause the fund manager to liquidate his holdings to raise cash. This is especially disruptive if the asset liquidated is illiquid since cost of liquidation is high (executing at bad prices and paying up bid-ask spreads etc).
Large funds that are regulated have to disclose some information on their holdings. This makes it more difficult for them to outmaneuver the market.
1. Lower Fees and Spreads
Big funds have better bargaining power and can negotiate lower execution cost. Retail traders pay high commission and spreads. In most cases, retail traders are taking prices as opposed to making prices (unless they trade using depth-of-market/2nd level systems). As a price taker, retail traders pay higher spreads.
2. Best Services and Wide Range of Products
Big funds have access to prime brokerage, other support services and a wide range of financial products. These support services spend countless hours researching and executing the best deals for the funds. Retail traders do not have this luxury.
3. Fast Information
Information is king. Funds have access to important information quicker than the general public. This gives them an edge.
4. Top Technology
Big funds invest top dollar into better infrastructure. These infrastructure aids their trading in terms of research/backtesting, execution and risk management. This allows them to engage in complex trades that the retail traders cannot access.
Funds have better credit rating than the average retail trader. Hence, they are able to get better leverage and terms. This allows them to weather tough times and increase returns with a smaller base capital.
Once we understand the different circumstances between the big boys and us, we should realise that the real question here is not “How to we outwit the big funds?”. It is “How do we find market inefficiencies that are untouched by the funds”.
Google will not touch a $20,000 per month revenue opportunity – it is too small. However, this is big enough for a one-man tech company. Similarly, we should target these pockets of alpha in the market, until we grow big enough to play in the same playground as the big boys.
AlgoTrading101 is the first comprehensive online course on algorithmic trading. Learn the fundamentals of algo trading and put your ideas into action along with more than 25,000 students. Learn more about us at AlgoTrading101.
Lucas has been designing and building algorithmic trading robots since 2010. He worked at a proprietary trading firm and taught programming for financial applications to Government of Singapore Investment Corporation (GIC), one of the largest sovereign wealth funds in the world. He runs this blog and the AlgoTrading101 course.